Guiding you through

Court Rules on Where Boy Should Attend Secondary School

When deciding issues relating to the care and upbringing of a child, the courts' primary consideration will always be the child's welfare. Recently, the Family Court was called upon to decide where a boy should attend secondary school, in the absence of agreement between his parents.

The boy was ten years old and was about to start his last year of primary school. His parents were separated and he lived with his mother, spending time with his father every other weekend and for longer periods during the school holidays. His father wanted him to attend a state secondary school, while his mother's preferred option was for him to go to a small independent school. They both agreed that he had additional educational needs, found change and transition difficult, and would benefit from practical and supportive learning. Both of the proposed schools could provide Special Education Needs and Disabilities support.

The Court had regard for the welfare checklist set out in Section 1(3) of the Children Act 1989, and observed that the boy's welfare was its paramount consideration in reaching its decision. The boy had not expressed strong views about either school but had said that most of his friends were going to the state school, and that where his friends went to school was very important to him.

About half of his primary school class would likely be going to the state school, including his best friend. The state school was significantly larger than his primary school and he might well see much less of his friends than he currently did, but they would be travelling to and from school together. None of his primary school friends would be attending the independent school. It was further away and new friends he made there would be likely to live quite a distance from his home. The Court considered that there was a risk that, if he went to the independent school, the pressure of the school fees and the effect they might have on the outcome of the parents' financial remedy proceedings could develop into a continuing source of tension or resentment between the parents, which could impact him negatively.

Having regard to all the evidence and the welfare checklist, the Court concluded that he should attend the state school. Going to school with his friends, including his best friend, would be a significant advantage for a child who struggled to adapt to change, and would mean he could attend induction days with his friends, talk with them about what he was excited or nervous about, and look forward to the change together with them. The school was also close to both of his parents' homes.

The contents of this article are intended for general information purposes only and shall not be deemed to be, or constitute legal advice. We cannot accept responsibility for any loss as a result of acts or omissions taken in respect of this article.